best of all:
Lara: " (.. I loveeed the pavement project :).... do you think, that this is the future? that we also will be building our pavements say on Holloway Road? "
YIS!
critics:
Lara - Design for London
Mark Clayton - head of CHUDS
Korean tutor
Eric
Crispin - developer
Jean Paul - tutor
Robert - head of school
U7 - Grandorge
missed (sorry)
U4 - UFO
.. we use the equivalent of freehand drawing in digital :))))) really?
R.M: explore the analog>digital , as well as digital>analogue
U12
Proposing little changes within small budget
Crispin: Do you think you are proposing anything better than the disfuncional allotments imposed by the council?
ouch
You are using the vocabulary of standard answers
me (thinking): working within the sys, instead of challenging it
3 consultations = participatory design? !
U6 - India
monuments and slums, heritage walks, exploiting tourist industry as an answer to poverty
tourism as an upgrade for slum
monments are objects rather than facilities (what they should be???)
mememe: (as Adam said: take the best feature of a city and make it better Rio DeJaneiro - lights for Copacabana beach)
Crispin: this is like gap year activity, architects suggesting things that will make people happier
U6: yes the role of an architect is changing
Cripsin: touchy-feely bottom up
what is space syntax?
Jean P: artificiallity
what could you do that a skilled sociologist couldn't do?
ouch
R.M: what you might bring this year, that you didn't any other years
you were architectural tourists (in india) dont be sheepish about it, use
it for your Tourism strategy!
ouch
U10 - Odessa
Crispin: Artistic sensibility, art school in action
programme - save the world agenda
are you interested in rephrasing the question? (what is a care home?)
R.M: twinning Odessa to a bit of London
Olympics >< centralized leisure in Odessa (recreation facilities)
Lara: How do we take pride in small v. large scale?
J. Paul: your interventions seem timid next to the bold sanatoriums
heroic buildings
power to resist and re-energize
U2 - Lynch
ruination :)
(same programs-apart from 1- as Odessa, now is this worrying?)
Jean P: presentation Caleidoscop, dizzy
Tutor from Korea: more architectural than just talking
Crispin: "layering" is used in archi context so much, Is there any merit?
Does it take more bravery to avoid collage?
Mark Clayton: Take a moment to decide what it is NOT.
FREE U - us
Mark Clayton: Is the cohesion (of people, and projects) real or fake?
Crispin (developer!): architects compete and collaborate, great energy
highly likely would sponsor
Jean Paul: you are dancing around architecture
Nicolas: sales pitch, hope it is more serious
Lara: Will this result into us layering out pavements on Holloway Road?
FREE: uuum yes
mememe: YES, please (i bloody wrote a whole essay about it)
xxx(persistent young man): contract is about your own delivery, what is the feedback?
U3 - east
docks
skills nills ?? - teaching by renovating vacant buildings - what a great idea!
game to interact with a community - how much better is playing than offensive asking. good!
Lara - the contrast of extreme community engagements >planning workshop v. games
Jean P: gathering of stories, do you have a concrete example of how to translate them?
R.M: the strategic planning is stories as well, both paradigms fail.
Crispin: Giving an architectural student a brief which is not a brief.
Does it really matter what your observation about the need for a library are?
ouch
U5 - art and sewage
a good restaurant is remembered but not noticed
victorian sewage moves the problem down the stream
venice city of industry (????) to city of culture
courtyards collect water, filter and store it, wells > drinking water.
(pumping station) loved beyond its usefulness
collage studio whose form reflects it.
Eric: will you question the overall?
Crispin: the wicked developer, brackets, me. There are too many architects and artists.
Most of the people you visit as artists will be forgotten. I wouldn't build a city around it.
ouch
U5: we need to in some way engage with our waste
Signy: Should infrastructure be more celebrated
Mark Clayton: Waste is critical in sustainability, do you care?
R.M: Comfort. the crossprograming is a distraction.
How to celebrate comfort, utility?
It is fantastic theses.
The few clattering artists are in a way.
U5: um. potentially
U9 -Stephen Taylor
typologies adjust to terrain (about the models of terraced houses that are on a slope and step down :)
heavy traffic (about a village)
dense urban core (of a village:)
extreme environment (in UK:)
in my opinion, there is nothing extreme apart from the conservative architecture.
Crispin: I can recognize the hand of the master.
How do you get to the proposal?
U9: we spent a day in each of the places, looking (!!!)
Lara: What would happen in 5 years time without your bold intervention?
Eric: Challenge to make more than 1 window per room
ouch
I have problem with grammar, reliance strictly on existing fabric. Lot of your proposals look like housing, yet you seem to be wanting to do anything but housing.
have you considered program? construction method? (anything?)
Mark Clayton: your choice of form is very close to the Georgian forms. Yet there is not much commonality between the original houses and the imposed Georgian import other than stone. It would not be hard to try what Foster would do, what Ghery would do. This is not question, this is provocation.
R.M: you need to quickly retrieve into the level of detail of the beginning.
U1 -Florian, ruins
Crispin: weak urbanism, people want to live in a house with a garden. But the metropolis wants them to live in a flat. What is your take on that?
Eric: The aura of the presentation numbed me to any criticism. I am searching for everyday.
Lara: What about eruption?
Nicholas: Alcais Alcons ( i didnt get what they were talking about, probably ruins)
Mark Clayton: Set of studies into time rather than building
What do you think of building contemporary onto 400BC or 19th century?
Signy: Where do you re-house people?
U1: The author is not here, probably best to ask him directly
U? - chora
sector T = Thames Gateway
sector E = EU?
game
mememe: game generated urbanism v. computer generated forms(U4)
Eric: How different is this going to be to villa ?????????? (didnt get that)
R.M: dictatorial
Mark Clayton: Are you adding the random?
Main part of gaming is winning. What does the winning look like?
Jean P: risk of sinking into banality
you are playing a game with such complex issues that you have no grasp of, frankly.
Superficial outcome of game.
ouch
Nicholas: provocative
Crispin: It doesn't seem to be a game I would want to play. Is that a waste of time?
Signy: To what extend are you playing with people outside of your world?
U11 - DSDHA
analysis of SOHO turned inside out into rules.
Crispin: you are reasonably anarchic
after all it is a set of rules, how is that different to others?
HOW do YOU have the capacity and intelligence ?
ouch
No comments:
Post a Comment